What's Hot

    Treat Yourself: Explore restored wetlands, more at Canastota’s Great Swamp Conservancy

    June 1, 2023

    Explore CNY: Cazenovia has something for every age

    June 1, 2023

    Summer Learning Loss is Real

    June 1, 2023
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Trending
    • Treat Yourself: Explore restored wetlands, more at Canastota’s Great Swamp Conservancy
    • Explore CNY: Cazenovia has something for every age
    • Summer Learning Loss is Real
    • 315 Bulletin
    • Berries and Cream Croissant Breakfast Casserole
    • Summer Activities Guide
    • A Day for Dad
    • Wondrous Waterfalls
    Facebook Twitter Instagram RSS
    Family TimesFamily Times
    • Community Guide
    • Things to Do in CNY
      1. Central New York Events
      2. Activities
      3. Treat Yourself
      Featured

      Treat Yourself: Explore restored wetlands, more at Canastota’s Great Swamp Conservancy

      By Courtney KlessJune 1, 202311
      Recent

      Treat Yourself: Explore restored wetlands, more at Canastota’s Great Swamp Conservancy

      June 1, 2023

      Explore CNY: Cazenovia has something for every age

      June 1, 2023

      Summer Activities Guide

      June 1, 2023
    • Parenting
      1. Pregnancy
      2. Babies
      3. Kids
      4. Preschoolers/Toddlers
      5. Special Needs
      6. Teens
      7. Pets
      8. View All

      The Power to Save a Life: Cord blood is being used to treat more than 80 diseases

      January 30, 2020

      It’s Not What It Looks Like: Reflections on motherhood’s changes, outside and inside

      July 29, 2019

      In Search of Sleep: 8 Strategies for coping with wakeful babies

      July 29, 2019

      A Surgical Birth: Many pregnant women are likely to deliver by cesarean

      July 29, 2019

      Strangers Bearing Advice: New babies bring out the expert in everyone

      August 1, 2021

      Hand to Mouth: How to help babies start to sample solid food

      August 1, 2020

      315 Bulletin

      August 1, 2020

      Name, Please? Expectant parents face another momentous decision

      August 1, 2020

      Prep Work: Keep your family’s food safe this summer

      June 1, 2022

      A Blooming Craft: These homemade flowers make a great centerpiece

      March 1, 2021

      Rainbow Snowflakes: A colorful craft even little ones can make

      November 24, 2020

      DIY Critter Magnets: Make cute clips for hanging reminders and more

      September 1, 2020

      DIY Critter Magnets: Make cute clips for hanging reminders and more

      September 1, 2020

      Allergy Adjustments: Parents can support their food allergic child

      September 3, 2019

      Calming Commotion: How to deal with car sickness and more

      June 27, 2019

      Introducing Riff Rockit: Kindie artist to play jingles at Leon Fest

      June 1, 2017

      A History of Inclusion: The Jowonio School marked 50 years in 2019

      March 30, 2020

      Reaching a Milestone: Now the largest chapter in the country, Special Olympics New York is celebrating 50 years

      March 30, 2020

      Come Out and Play: Move Along offers adaptive sports for youth, adults

      March 30, 2020

      Let’s Get Together: Remaking classrooms so all students are included

      September 3, 2019

      Prep Work: Keep your family’s food safe this summer

      June 1, 2022

      A Little Jolt: Caffeine’s risks for kids and teens

      March 1, 2021

      A Blooming Craft: These homemade flowers make a great centerpiece

      March 1, 2021

      Environmental Club: Auburn Junior High School

      January 30, 2020

      Furry Friends: What it takes to adopt a pet for the first time

      July 1, 2020

      Tail Wagging Fun: Lights on the Lake Dog Walk 2019

      November 14, 2019

      Uncommon Companions: Local pet store sticks to its niche

      May 30, 2019

      Dog Food for Thought: Trying to keep your pet from your plate

      May 30, 2019

      Summer Learning Loss is Real

      June 1, 2023

      A Day for Dad

      June 1, 2023

      Crash Course: Help your child brush up on study skills for final exams

      May 1, 2023

      A Day Just for Mom: Mother’s Day celebrations and gifts she’ll treasure

      May 1, 2023
    • Health
      1. Child Development
      2. Food
      3. Nutrition
      4. The “Recipe Doctor”
      5. View All

      Financial Literacy for Families: How parents can teach children, teens about money management

      April 1, 2022

      Strangers Bearing Advice: New babies bring out the expert in everyone

      August 1, 2021

      Choosing a Daycare: Learn As You Grow’s Joshua LaGrow offers some tips for finding the right fit

      August 1, 2021

      A Little Jolt: Caffeine’s risks for kids and teens

      March 1, 2021

      Berries and Cream Croissant Breakfast Casserole

      June 1, 2023

      Prep Work: Keep your family’s food safe this summer

      June 1, 2022

      Nutrition in No Time: Are you always on the go? These tips will help you stay on track.

      January 1, 2022

      Easy Holiday Recipes: Are you searching for some new dishes this season? These are some of our favorites.

      November 1, 2021

      Nutrition in No Time: Are you always on the go? These tips will help you stay on track.

      January 1, 2022

      Liking Lunch: Best bets for serving kids a delicious, nutritious meal

      September 1, 2021

      A Little Jolt: Caffeine’s risks for kids and teens

      March 1, 2021

      Better Choices: How about a resolution to eat vegetables and other nutritious foods?

      January 1, 2021

      Best Friend’s Treats: Bake up some special dog biscuits

      June 1, 2018

      Colorful Soup in a Jar: Give the gift of winter comfort

      December 1, 2015

      Berry Good! Use a summer favorite in this ice cream

      July 1, 2015

      Flapjack Fever: Even pancakes can be a healthy breakfast

      June 1, 2015

      Treat Yourself: Explore restored wetlands, more at Canastota’s Great Swamp Conservancy

      June 1, 2023

      Berries and Cream Croissant Breakfast Casserole

      June 1, 2023

      Treat Yourself: Watch a show – or two – at Redhouse Arts Center

      May 1, 2023

      315 Bulletin

      May 1, 2023
    • Travel
    • Education
      1. Educator of the Month
      2. Class of the Month
      3. Education News
      4. Reading
      5. Teaching
      Featured

      Summer Learning Loss is Real

      By Kimberly BlakerJune 1, 20236
      Recent

      Summer Learning Loss is Real

      June 1, 2023

      Lzay Colella, Lead Instructor for Le Moyne College’s Summer Arts Institute Musical Theatre Camp

      June 1, 2023

      Ben Borenstein, Education Coordinator at Redhouse Arts Center

      May 1, 2023
    • Crafts & DIY
      • Create
      • Holiday Crafts
    Family TimesFamily Times
    Home»Education»Why Tests Fail: Standardized exams don’t help students
    Education

    Why Tests Fail: Standardized exams don’t help students

    Michael GilbertBy Michael GilbertApril 1, 2015Updated:February 13, 2019No Comments0 Views
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    In April, public school students in grades 3 through 8 will take Common Core ELA (English Language Arts) and mathematics tests required by the New York State Testing Program. The testing occurs April 14 through 16 for ELA and April 22 through 24 for math.

    Many parents have questions about these exams, and there has been a great deal of debate regarding their merit. But the concerns are not just about the tests; it’s the year-round impact of the increased emphasis on testing. There has been an ongoing focus in the media regarding the idea that American schools are failing when compared with other nations. Both the No Child Left Behind law and Race to the Top educational competition grants are built on this false narrative. This misguided, test-driven thinking has dominated the U.S. public education system for the past two decades and ultimately has led to our current predicament.

    On international tests, American students don’t appear to do very well, but the truth is they never have—not since 1964 when the first such test was completed. The United States was never a world leader on these international tests and its students’ scores have typically been at the median or even lower. During these years, the U.S. often outperformed other nations in more essential areas, such as overall economy and technological advances. Perhaps most important to note is that these test scores are not even a valid predictor of economic prosperity or of global competitiveness.

    What are often overlooked in these comparisons are factors such as poverty. When poverty is taken into consideration, American students rate quite favorably on international comparisons. In fact, in schools where less than 10 percent of students get free or reduced lunch, U.S. students were No. 2 on the international ranking for reading.

    Poverty is a problem, not our schools. Among the nations taking these international tests, we have the highest rate of child poverty. There is always room for improvement in the education system, but we are actually seeing a decline in performance as a result of new reform policies and increased testing.

    Most agree that there is a role for standardized tests—if they are limited in duration and frequency, developmentally appropriate, and provide useful feedback for classroom instruction. New York state tests fail to meet these standards and are misused for school accountability purposes.

    In addition, there really is no meaningful benefit for students. The tests don’t affect their report cards or grade placement. Unfortunately, many students will still feel a sense of pressure and stress surrounding the tests. Some might argue that students need to learn how to take this type of test and handle the anxiety that might accompany it. However, there are probably better ways to accomplish this goal. Some high-performing countries wait until high school before administering standardized tests and instead focus on developing life skills.

    The excessive focus on testing also has had negative effects on the quality of education. The state tests have narrowed the curriculum. Subjects such as science, social studies, art and music get short shrift. In elementary schools, children are being required to perform tasks that are developmentally inappropriate, and there is less time for recess, unstructured play and physical education. Less time for creative learning, critical thinking and social-emotional skills. Limited funds are funneled away from direct resources for students. Current policies actually stifle and undermine the necessary and notably American traits of imagination, creativity and innovation that make this country a leader in so many ways.

    Another drawback is that results of state tests are not available to teachers and parents until the student has already started the next grade. Clearly individual feedback about a child’s strengths and challenges is not being provided. Teachers know our kids; they are working with them throughout the school year and using assessments that are already completed in the classroom. Yet another significant problem is the inappropriateness of tests given to English language learners and special education students.

    Unfortunately, state test scores are used inappropriately to evaluate your child’s teachers. Using test scores to hold teachers accountable has no research to support it. There is no evidence that the tests produce better teachers or better education. Studies find that teachers account for only a small percentage of the variability in test scores. The majority of the variation in test scores is attributable to factors outside of the teacher’s control. Doing well in school depends on family and community support, student motivation, adequate resources, appropriate class sizes, experienced teachers and students who arrive to school healthy, well-fed and cared for.

    Education is not a race. It is about the growth and development of every child. It’s about having the opportunity to develop one’s abilities and pursue one’s passions. We have a natural love for learning, and education should provide an environment that is engaging, challenging, motivating, safe and joyful.

    So when it comes to annual New York state testing, it’s not just about the test. It is about the larger picture of public education.

    Most students will take the annual tests, and we should encourage them to do their best. However, we shouldn’t overemphasize them. If your child is nervous about the tests, talk to him and reassure him.

    Children should put forth their best efforts, but tell them that they are not expected to know all the answers. Relaxation, mindfulness or other approaches might also help.

    Some parents will choose to refuse state tests. There are different reasons some parents opt out, but the main reason is to bring change to a system that is failing our children. It is essential that parents understand they have a voice in the future of their child’s education. Talk to teachers and principals about the current state of education, attend a school board meeting, or call or write your local and state legislator.

    Testing may always be a part of our public education system, but that doesn’t mean we need to sacrifice the quality of education or the development of the whole child.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email
    Michael Gilbert

    Related Posts

    Summer Learning Loss is Real

    June 1, 2023

    Lzay Colella, Lead Instructor for Le Moyne College’s Summer Arts Institute Musical Theatre Camp

    June 1, 2023

    Ben Borenstein, Education Coordinator at Redhouse Arts Center

    May 1, 2023
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    Top Posts

    Summer Activities Guide

    June 1, 202330

    Wondrous Waterfalls

    June 1, 202325

    Lzay Colella, Lead Instructor for Le Moyne College’s Summer Arts Institute Musical Theatre Camp

    June 1, 202318

    Treat Yourself: Watch a show – or two – at Redhouse Arts Center

    May 1, 202315
    Flip Through Our Latest Issue!
    Recent Posts
    • Treat Yourself: Explore restored wetlands, more at Canastota’s Great Swamp Conservancy
    • Explore CNY: Cazenovia has something for every age
    • Summer Learning Loss is Real
    • 315 Bulletin
    • Berries and Cream Croissant Breakfast Casserole

    Family Times Magazine publishes a digital magazine highlighting events, businesses, and content to inform and entertain families here in Central New York. Sign up for our twice monthly newsletter to have the magazine and other featured content.
    ____

    Email Us: [email protected]
    Contact: 1.315.422.7011

    Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn RSS
    Our Picks

    Treat Yourself: Explore restored wetlands, more at Canastota’s Great Swamp Conservancy

    June 1, 2023

    Explore CNY: Cazenovia has something for every age

    June 1, 2023

    Summer Learning Loss is Real

    June 1, 2023
    Most Popular

    Summer Activities Guide

    June 1, 202330

    Wondrous Waterfalls

    June 1, 202325

    Lzay Colella, Lead Instructor for Le Moyne College’s Summer Arts Institute Musical Theatre Camp

    June 1, 202318
    © 2023 All Times Publishing. Designed by Crossroads Media Productions.
    • Our Authors
    • Archives
    • Community Events Calendar
    • Advertising

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Go to mobile version